Home » When Filing a Lawsuit What Court Should I Be In?

When Filing a Lawsuit What Court Should I Be In?

To file a lawsuit, you have two options. You can sue on the state level or you can sue in the federal court system.

How do you know where your case belongs? And what are the advantages of each option?

A person bringing a lawsuit only two ways to hear a case in federal court. A federal court needs “subject matter jurisdiction” to hear a case.  Subject Matter Jurisdiction is basically checking to see if a court is authorized by the law to hear a case.  Federal courts are courts of limited jurisdiction, so to find subject matter jurisdiction, you either need diversity jurisdiction or be based on a federal question.

Federal question is a case is based on a federal law. A case can be heard in the federal courts if it is in one area of law where the federal courts have original jurisdiction, such as securities law, maritime law, patent law, or cases where an individual is suing the United States.

A case based on diversity jurisdiction means that both parties (Defendant and Plaintiff) must be domiciled in a different state.  Being domiciled means living in a state intending to remain there indefinitely. Additionally, the amount in controversy needs to exceed $75,000.

If a case cannot be heard in federal court, then it should be in state court. And then those cases could be heard in either state or federal court. If so, what do you do? Well, that all depends on the state and your ultimate goal. Certain states are known for having slower courts. Other states are known for having more favorable outcomes in certain types of disputes or matters. Each state is different.

To determine what is best for you, research your state and consult with an experienced lawyer who can help determine the optimal course for your matter.

Contact Brinen & Associates



I Got a Summons and Complaint in the Mail? What Do I Do?

Receiving a summons and complaint in the mail may seem terrifying at first. For many people, their first instinct might be to just throw it in the trash and hope that their problem goes away. Hoping is not a plan, and is the last thing they should do. If you receive a...

read more

What is a 30(b)(6) Deposition?

Under the Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 30(b)(6), a party may depose – or ask questions of - public or private corporations, partnerships, associations, or other entities. To do this, the party needs to subpoena the public or private corporations, partnerships,...

read more

What To Do If You Haven’t Filed a Tax Return In Years

It may come as a surprise, but each year there are many, many Americans who simply do not file a tax return. Each person who does not file their tax return has many reasons this happens. For some, it could be because of physical or mental health issues that prevented...

read more

How to Handle a Subpoena From the SEC

Receiving a subpoena from the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) may seem daunting at first. If you do receive one, the first thing you should do is take a deep breath and not panic. You should assess your situation, and ultimately—and calmly—proceed with the...

read more